You probably think you know who Doug Benson is. Heralded for projects like Super High Me and “Marijuana-Logues,” it’s understandable why one might pigeonhole Benson as just That Guy Who Talks About Pot. If you think Benson is a bit of a stoner, you’d be right. If you assume a lot of Benson’s material will be rooted in that very topic, you’d also be right. But if you think that’s all Benson is…you would be very, very wrong.
On his new album Potty Mouth, Benson proves that although it’s true he’s down with the green stuff, he is first and foremost an accomplished comedian.This is no one-trick pony and Benson shatters any pre-conceived notions you may have held by displaying an amazing knack for bringing huge laughs with material both scripted and off-the-cuff. The prepared material he has scrawled in his notebook proves to be just as funny as his crowd work — and vice versa. Whether he’s reading Tweets written by his fans (and himself), responding to unsolicited audience participation, or marveling at the jokes he hastily scribbled on a Post-It note, Benson thrives. Although his stage persona is one of a relaxed, “whatever dude” kinda guy, don’t let it fool you. Benson is no slacker. Quite the opposite, he’s a comedy machine, cranking out one huge laugh after another.
One of the first things that stood out to me was the fact that Benson doesn’t get to a written joke until the third track. Where most comedians will open up with a throwaway hello and jump right in, Benson spends the first ten (count ’em, ten!) minutes interacting with the crowd, riffing on the venue’s name and location, and checking his Twitter feed to see what people in the audience are saying about the show so far. Benson tries to downplay the fact he’s getting so many big laughs by posing the question, “Did we just pay money to just watch you read tweets from your phone?” but the fact of the matter is, it’s killing. This guy could be reading an episode summary of Six Feet Under from tv.com and he’d still turn it into great material. It’s not what he’s doing that’s funny (yes, as a matter of fact he is just reading tweets from his phone) but it’s because it’s Benson who’s doing it that makes it so much fun. His initial reactions and responses to each tweet are proof positive that he is as good at improvisation as anyone on the circuit.
And then, of course, we get to the material he has come prepared with. When Benson says he wrote down everything he wanted to talk about, he meant it. At the top of the first page it says, “Hey everybody” and the bottom of the last page says – SPOILER ALERT! – “Thank you, good night.” Benson has some great stories stolen from real-life experiences and although many of them have to do with being a little less-than clear-headed, his stories aren’t just for pot smokers. His comedy is broad enough to include everyone in the room and no one feels left out.
Which brings up a good point. Listening back to the recording, you can hear that it’s not just people in the first few rows laughing. Benson has the entire room in stitches and a lot of it has to do with the fact that he’s so friggin’ likable. Whatever your stance is on marijuana, astrology, or bacon sundaes, you’ll find yourself on Benson’s side. He’s not unlike Mitch Hedberg in that respect. Everyone knew he was blitzed most of the time, but doggonit, everyone couldn’t help but love him. The difference between Hedberg and Benson in the party of life is a simple one: While Hedberg would be off to the side of the room next to the fireplace mumbling his sharp insight to a small group of people huddled around him, Benson is the guy greeting you at the door with a big hug and a smile. He takes your coat and yells to the room, “Hey everybody! Look who’s here!” Benson is the guy at the party that instantly makes you glad you decided to go to the party.
He has a great bit about his trip to a grocery store and the response he gave when asked if he wanted a bag for his items. The tale of some guys who wanted to show Benson hospitality after a show by smoking with him out in the middle of nowhere is a riot and when he talks about marijuana turning his brain into mush on a CNN appearance (“What?”), I absolutely lost it when orphans and Pauly Shore ended up in the mix.
For many reviewers, this would be the part of the write-up where I try to think of something I didn’t like about the project. For me, though, this is the part where I admit there’s nothing about this I would change. I’m not so vain to think I could have done any better or that there’s something Benson should have done differently. The bottom line is, this CD is funny. It’s non-stop funny and Benson deserves sincere congratulations on a job well done.
I guess that’s why this blog is called “Comedy Reviews” and not “Comedy Critiques.” There’s really nothing here to critique. I’ve got nothing but good things to say about this one and I couldn’t be happier about it. I guess that’s what happens when someone as talented and skilled as Benson takes to the stage.
Or maybe it’s just what happens when someone has a Potty Mouth.